True Kindness

Introduction

True kindness is a rare thing to see in society - and I’ve been on both the giving and the receiving end of it a few times, and recently an X post plus my own circumstances prompted me to write this article.

First, to define true kindness, it’s simply as:

Kindness that gives without expectation of a return - in other words, doing something for someone without receiving something back.

I would like to talk about my own experiences, what prompted me to change, and how it feels on both ends of this spectrum.

My Story - On the Receiving End

There were two times where kindness was shown to me, where I behaved poorly in return, and my mind was already on this topic when I saw the following tweet:

In the above tweet, the image doesn’t come up, but it’s of a kid who invited 30 others to their birthday party, only to have none of them show up. I immediate gave my story:

This also made me reflect, but I’ll get to that later. In the case of this story - it’s very much a true one, and one where I behaved poorly. Either out of sheer laziness, or pure disregard - I disregarded the teacher’s feelings, didn’t attend, and ended up regretting it. I do remember her words, it simply “The dogs ate well that morning.”

In the same X thread, someone replied that the parents shouldn’t make the children go. My response to this is the children should have wanted to go. If the children were brought up right, and they’re friends of this kid, they should want to go - not because they get something out of it, but because it brings their friend happiness.

Another case where this happened to me is when I was in community college. I was in a World Religions class, was a pretty strict Catholic (upbringing), and while interested in other religions - I thought myself “superior” to those religions. There was a Buddhist group that was presenting, and I challenged some of their beliefs - but not in a respectful way. They were kind explaining their position, but I came off poorly - a bad decision on my part. What’s ironic about it is I now study the very religion that I was condemning at the time, although a different variant.

These two cases really helped embed into my brain one simple thing:

When true kindness shows up at your doorstep, don’t be so quick to push it away - it’s rare in society.

One other thing I learned over time is the majority of people are very much wrapped up in their “own problems” to think of anyone else, their perspective, or their motivations. Along with this, because their “own problems” often times include some element of greed (which a form of protection can be of), most people are very much self-serving.

One area of pride, if I want to call it that, of mine is that I learned not to look outward for measures of my own self-worth. If I can look in the mirror and say “I did my best” or “I’m trying”, then I’m satisfied - in the case of this section, one core principle of mine is “least harm” - which kindness is a part of that. Every day I strive to show kindness toward at least one person or animal each day. This week are some examples:

  1. Daily squirrel/animal feeding: Even with us coming to winter, I feed the animals daily.
  2. Field Mouse: There was a field mouse that took shelter in my garage recently. I bought no-kill traps, caught it, and released it in foilage where it has a better chance of surviving.
  3. Neighbor’s garbage can: A neighbor had their garbage can tipped over in their rock garden. I picked it out. Ironic enough, I got a text from them saying they saw it, thanked me, and we talked about hosting a board-game event at their house for a few of the more friendly neighbors in my neighborhood. We’re meeting tomorrow.
  4. Candy/cat for a 4-year old: A direct neighbor of mine has a 4-year old girl, who at this point, is almost always on the lookout for me and runs up each time she can. This turned into multiple times a week, she has her own jug of M&Ms that she picks from each time.
  5. Coaching a neighborhood kid: There’s a kid in the neighborhood who I’ve been talking through some challenges he’s having at school.
  6. Inner work/prayers for a family: I’ll talk about them below, but prayers for their health/wellbeing.

These are all things this week alone. My point in listing all these out isn’t to say “Hey, look - I’m a good guy!”, but to give examples. Every day I try to show some form of kindness to someone - doing something that may not gain any real recognition. Showing small acts of kindness helps me to look in the mirror and be proud of myself. Hopefully, this can encourage people to take a bit of energy, applying it outward showing care.

My Story - On the Giving End

This story hits hard for me, and I spoke about this multiple times over the past few months. But as a quick recap - there’s someone who I have feelings for (and, if I’m being honest, I think the “first”), care about, and at least felt like I resonnate with to some degree (it feels like less so now than in the past). During her early days of recovery, we resonnated quite a bit - even so far that she used my name as part of her autonomy desires. She had feelings for me, and I suspect still does - but we’ll get to that later.

Because the family is a very much “family first” and “contain as much as possible” like environment, the family as a whole (including mainly the father), made what was supposed to be a minor mole-hill, a connection that I feel would have not only benefitted her but the whole family, into a large “mountain” to overcome. The father, which I’ll just call Ja for the rest of this story, explicitly and implicitly blocked - and I suspect even before her recovery started. In addition to that, nearly every exchange that we had was met with two outcomes - either entire disrespect/disregard to me, and usually followed up by a retreat and seclusion (which is the current state). In other words, for the 8 or so months I’ve known Ja, our relationship has been rocky at best - despite doing everything I can to be a positive influence, supporting them as best I can - I’ve been met with nothing but unkindness.

Why? To this day I’m still unsure. When I originally met Ja, I actually strove to be friends - which was quickly shut down before even the recovery started (plus, was met with very much a defensive/retreat attitude). As the iChing puts it, this comes up a lot for Ja (and lately Je too):

His house is in a state of abundance. He screens off his family. He peers through the gate And no longer perceives anyone. For three years he sees nothing. Misfortune. This describes a man who because of his arrogance and obstinacy attains the opposite of what he strives for. He seeks abundance and splendor for his dwelling. He wishes at all odds to be master in his house, which so alienates his family that in the end he finds himself completely isolated.

Anyways, where this story is going is not everyone will accept kindness shown, nor help if one needs kindness back - and kindness can be met with suspicion, defensiveness, disregard, and at times hatred. In this story’s case, I’ve given a lot - “holding space” (trying to make this mountain a bit lower by making myself visible - even at discomfort for me) for months when I could, prayers/inner-work nearly everyday, providing materials to aid in recovery, and through just trying to be the best person I can be - waving to Je as a form of “hey, you’re seen, noticed, and valued - you’re not alone”, and an attempt to be a good role model. After this length of time, even Je (the person I feel I ressonate with) is now withdrawing even harder - and that I don’t understand either. In other words, the messaging I’m getting now is “We don’t want you around us, go away” - whether this is their intended messaging or not.

When I was casting along the iChing around some of all this, there was an interesting transformation line that kept coming up, especially recently:

He brings increase to no one. Indeed, someone even strikes him. He does not keep his heart constantly steady. Misfortune. The meaning here is that through renunciation those in high place should bring increase to those below. By neglecting this duty and helping no one, they in turn lose the furhtering influence of others and soon find themselves alone. In this way they invite attacks. An attitude not permanently in harmony with the demands of the time will necessarily bring misfortune with it. Confucius says about this line: The superior man sets his person at rest before he moves; he composes his mind before he speaks; he makes his relations firm before he asks for something. By attending to these three matters, the superior man gains complete security. But if a man is brusque in his movements, others will not cooperate. If he is agitated in his word, they awaken no echo in others. If he asks for something without having fist established relations, it will not be given to him. If no one is with him, those who would harm him draw near.

This line was quite important for me to see, casting it from their perspective (Je, or Ja - which is advice from the oracle to them), because it’s true in life. In my opinion, we gain pride by giving to others as best we can. If we don’t give, then nothing can be received. I’ll give an example.

Last weekend, I was really sad about this situation above - we’re talking depression territory. From my perspective, this connection I really wanted however innocent in expression, is being curbed by both Je and Ja - and for some odd reason (Oracle implies various levels of pride plus approach/avoid). In addition, they have to know that this situation hurts, but are unwilling to provide any energy back my direction (e.g. the one connection Je and I had, waves, stopped). On Saturday, I was going to get some Pizza - simply needing to get out of the house, and a friend contacted me “out of the blue”, wanting to spend time with me. I thought about it - I felt like crap, hurting quite bad - it would have been all too easy to say “No, I need some time alone”, but this person went out of their way to contact me - either by coincidence or seeing my poor mood and secluded atmosphere. Instead, I said “yes”, and we ended up spending the entire afternoon together. We biked to a nearby trail, and hiking for over an hour. This connection formed within the last 6 months, and one I appreciate quite a lot. I also thanked them multiple times for helping me out like they did, because that time together did pull me out of my rut, at least temporarily, which helped.

So, where I brought - at least the best I could, enrichment to people’s lives nearby, some accepted this and others didn’t. In the case of Je/Ja above, it wasn’t accepted particularly well, but to others in the area? I’ve gained a lot of trust and am on good terms with nearly everyone. And, when I was in a really dark place? One of those connections came through, helping me when I really needed it.

In the story above - what hope do I have that things will improve? Not much if I’m being honest. What I do know is that assumptions of intent is likely had on both ends - but the constant seclusion and avoidance makes any real conversation impossible. I provided material to help with the approach/avoid in hopes to remove one barrier, months ago, to have that entirely neglected - even if I told my own story suffering from the same situation years ago. I provided a letter, including my phone number, some weeks ago trying to explain intention and make the mountain even smaller so at least something can happen, only to be met with a very disrespectful one-way conversation from Ja, that was anything but kind, and very likely Je hasn’t even seen or read the letter.

In addition to that, even if they were to “come around” at some point, I’m not sure I’d still be there in the same manner (or at all). The reason is simple - their moral fabric is highly questionable if kindness is only met with disregard and at a times hatred - trust has been lost. Trust, for me, is my largest personality defect - once lost, it’s hard to build back up.

Does it hurt? yeah a lot. Do I wish that they’d stop secluding/hiding? yeah. Do I wish that some form of open dialogue resolving the past could happen? again yeah…. especially since, at least for Ja specifically I consistently get “contemplation” and “through the crack of the door” (shown below):

Contemplation through the crack of the door. Furthering for the perseverance of a woman. Through the crack of the door one has a limited outlook; one looks outward from within. Contemplation is subjectively limited. One tends to relate everything to oneself and cannot put oneself in another’s place and understand his motives. This is appropriate for a good housewife. It is not necessary for her to be conversant with the affairs of the world. But for a man who must take active part in public life, such a narrow, egotistic way of contemplating things is of course harmful.

Meaning, my letter was likely unread by either person, and my motives - however pure, is potentially twisted. And, for what? See the image at the top - that’s a picture of a “get well” present I purchased on the weekend she got out of the hospital, in hopes Je and I (and likely even Ja) would have put it together outside, a metaphore for rebuilding one’s life. This was during the first month after Je got back, which ironically the first 2.5 months of recovery, despite the pure containment, was the most hopeful unlike now.

Will this resolve in any positive manner? I’m not hopeful, to be honest and that’s what hurts the most. Hundreds of hours, time and care, met with the opposite - a beneficial connection with no hope in sight. Given the approach/avoid plus pride, getting over the initial hill (the approach/avoid) is likely never to happen at the rate it’s going - and a friendship, a light one at that, can’t even develop because everything’s in isolation. Will I still try to show kindness? Yes - even if guarded. I did make promises to myself (four such promises, one of them below) about Je, stated as:

I accept you for who you are, however you come (or not come) eventually to me.

Right now, I’m assuming nothing will transpire even if my original goal was us growing/learning from each other, but this - along with the other promises, are being held at least. The only thing I can hope for is if both are getting what they want from life, and are happy - with themselves, or with the outcomes. I don’t mean that sarcastically, I really do mean it - as long as both can look in the mirror and say “I’m proud of myself, and I’m happy with how this is all turning out”, then that’s all that matters.

Takeaways

My hope in telling this story is two fold. First, I believe we gain pride and dignity by the positive impact we have on people’s lives. This takes a certain amount of humility and at times self-sacrifice, but speaking from personal experience, it does help one to feel better. And, sometimes that help and sacrifice can pay off.

Second, is don’t expect a return on investment in all cases - not everyone is kind, and many aren’t. Do good acts because it brings you satisfaction, not expectation of a return.

Third - be careful how much you open your heart. In the case with me, I opened it quite wide, and have experienced some of the worst emotional pain I’ve had to go through before and still do. A lesson for me is things need to be gradual, if at all. This is a new area of my life, and a very painful series of lessons at that.

I hope this blog post helps at least some people. I’ll likely write another article on the iChing - because this specifically has been invaluable as a guide.

David Thole

David Thole
Senior Software Architect, Developer, Instructor. Reads/studies a lot and enjoys all things technology

Self Nourishment Amidst Uncertainty

IntroductionRecently, I found myself “crashing” to a degree. I’ve had this happen in the past, usually due to over work, but this time wa...… Continue reading

Compassion Amongst Uncertainty

Published on April 26, 2026